Where in Superior?

Meghan Callahan solved this one on Facebook. It's the Hammond Steakhouse.

By the way, I hadn't been to the Hammond in years and had a great dinner there last weekend. But what I really want to note is that, much like the Anchor Bar has "the Library" as its coveted place to sit, at the Hammond you should make your reservation for "the Octagon." 

(Note: It might be just me that calls it "the Octagon," but I doubt it.)