What are “Essential” Services?

Yesterday, across Minnesota, battered women’s shelters closed their doors. Why? Not for lack of need, but for lack of priority by the state. So far shelters and childcare for low-income families have been placed in the “non-essential” services category. What then are “essential” services and who gets to decide?

10 Comments

adam

about 13 years ago

Essential services: elected official's paychecks.

ironic1

about 13 years ago

Apparently "essential" services are services for the rich and middle class.  "Non-essential" services are for the poor and marginalized.

Claire

about 13 years ago

Man, you said it Ironic1.

Sam

about 13 years ago

Ironic1 got it right.  

But seriously, what SHOULD be essential is safety.  But we spend little money on safety for battered women, homeless children, and trafficked girls.  The rich just don't see the safety of these people as being as important as paying low taxes (God forbid the rich pay the same tax rate as the rest of us).

And we know that access to education and health care makes people's lives much safer, but the current budget makes deep cuts in those essentials as well.  Penny wise, pound foolish short term thinking that is going to hurt a lot of people (and in the end hurt the rich as well, who will spend more money on gated communities, alarm systems, and higher pay for the few educated people left in Minnesota).

Bret

about 13 years ago

According to Miller/Coors Beer, their nasty canned beverages they call "beer" are essential.

Other than that, Ironic1 and Sam are right on.

edgeways

about 13 years ago

Word is the impasse has ended. Sounds like a special session will be called soon. It is more kicking the can down the road nonsense and Dayton isn't happy with it, but with 20K+ workers laid off and the state loosing revenue each day...

The only thing I can say at this point is to hope the legislature changes hands next year, or we'll go through exactly the same thing in 2013.

Sam

about 13 years ago

The mission of government is to provide the essentials, the necessities that protect and empower citizens. The "essential necessities" are the things every decent human life needs, including education, health, protection, and opportunities.

Protection and safety include health care, social security, safe food, consumer protection, environmental protection, job protection, etc. Empowerment is what makes a decent life possible -- roads and infrastructure, communication and energy systems, education, etc. No business can survive without these goods secured within the community.

Adequate food, water, housing, transportation, education, infrastructure (roads and bridges, sewers, public buildings), medical care, care for elders, the disabled, environmental protection, food safety, clean air, and so on, are the necessities that give the opportunities for a basically decent, active human life.  If a society lacks one of these things for their citizens, that society fails.

Government also provides for public goods.  Education is not only essential to safety and a decent human life, but is also a public good. It benefits all of us to live in a country with educated people. It benefits corporations to have access to a large pool of educated employees. It benefits democracy to have educated citizens who rule wisely.

But only considering education as a means to make money, and hence as a private good, leads us to eliminate the public funding of education (as this MN budget does). This is a major disaster for all of us, not just those who will either be denied an education or who will be forced into huge debt, but for business and democracy as well.

wildknits

about 13 years ago

Well said Sam!!!!

zra

about 13 years ago

An uneducated populace is easier to control.

Makoons

about 13 years ago

Wow, I wish I had seen this post back when the shutdown was still going on...I would have had some serious choice words. I was laid-off from Dabinoo'igan Native American Battered Women's Shelter during this time, something very stressful for me and extremely stressful for the two families staying with us at the time. We had to shoo them out to superior or distant relative's homes and close up shop.

Leave a Comment

Only registered members can post a comment , Login / Register Here